Skip to main content

A Rejoinder To “Stray Bullet Murder: The Owerri Episode And The Position Of The Nigerian Law”





A Guest Post By
E.S.O. Ogholaja,
Delta State, Nigeria



An African adage says that when a person throws a stone in the open market, the stone may hit his father on the head. The Owerri saga is not only touching but it has raised much dust in the already troubled Nigerian polity as it concerns proving the offence of murder.
While we admire and respect the views of Ehiwe O. Sam on this matter in his article, we cannot agree with him. The fons et origo of our view is rooted in the following reasons:
Firstly, it is our view that it is the offence of murder and not manslaughter that was committed in the Owerri saga. Our position is judicially backed by the case of Uguru V. State (2007) 9 NWLR (pt. 771) at p. 90 where the court held that for the offence of murder to be established, the following elements must be present:
The victim is dead
The death of the victim was caused by the act(s) of the accused person
Death was a probable consequence of the act of the accused person.
A similar decision was reached in Nwosu V. State (1998) 8 NWLR (Pt. 562), Adekunle v. State (2006) 6 NWLR (pt. 534) and a plethora of other cases. Now, juxtaposing the above mentioned elements with the facts enunciated in the Owerri saga, the following conclusion will be arrived at:
The boy is dead judging from pictures and videos available to us and everywhere in the media
It is also an open fact that the boy’s death was caused by the sinister and corrosive bullet oozing from the rustic gun of one of the soldiers employed by Governor Rochas to cleanse the market.
We admit that the third element is legally problematic however; it is our submission that shooting sporadically in an open market constitutes an intention to kill. The proviso to section 24 of the Criminal Code of Nigeria is to the effect that one will be held liable for an offence if the intention (no matter how little it is) is coupled with the physical actions. In the celebrated case of Mancini v. DPP (1942) AC, the court held that the offence of murder is said to have been completed where the cause of death is a probable consequence of the act of the accused person. This case was quoted with approval in the Nigerian case of Iromantu v. State (1964) 1ALL NLR 311. Hence we humbly submit that shooting sporadically in an open market constituted enough intention to kill which acted as causation to the death of the boy. It is on this note that we find it difficult to agree with Ehiwe that manslaughter will be the most appropriate offence to link the Owerri saga.
In conclusion, if not for the immunity enjoyed by the governor, he would have been dancing in the cork tile where a charge of murder is the master of ceremony.

Comments

Lambonation said…
This comment has been removed by the author.
2 September 2017 at 05:31
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Nigerian Bar Association: A Body in Dire Need of Corporate Governance

By Peter Akinnusi At this year’s National Executive Council, NEC meeting of the Nigerian Bar Association, NBA in Ilorin, Kwara State, the President of the NBA, Abubakar Balarabe Mahmoud (SAN), seemed hard-pressed to stress the need to introduce corporate governance and efficient structural management at the Bar.This much has been apparent for quite a while now. He had previously engaged leading consulting firm, KPMG, to carry out an audit, and the report which was presented at the very same NEC meeting did not make for palatable reading. It highlighted the apparent lack of corporate governance culture in the NBA, and how much the NBA was riddled with structural defects ranging from blurred hierarchical lines to less-than-ideal financial and revenue management, as well as anaemic standards for staff job descriptions, evaluation, and training.In other words, the need to inject corporate governance into the NBA has been long overdue. However, this is not the time to dwell...
Post a Comment
Read more

Torn Between Two Worlds

By Nwokocha, Chidinma Grace Lagos, Nigeria Email: chidinmag.nwokocha@yahoo.com Mr. Chukwudi Ikpeama esq. is a legal practitioner with Chukwudi Ikpeama & Associates. He was called to the Nigerian Bar in the year 2000 and has since practiced as a Barrister and Solicitor of the Supreme Court of Nigeria in Nnewi, his hometown where he specializes in Property transactions as well as litigations arising from them. Aside being an accomplished property practitioner, he is also the President of the Christian Lawyers Fellowship of Nigeria (CLASFON), Nnewi Chapter and has served for two consecutive terms. Mr. Chukwudi esq. remembers with fondness some of the briefs that gave him the needed push when he commenced his professional career. In particular, he remembers Chief Emeka Ezego, the Oshimili Atata 1 of Nnewi who retained his services immediately after his call. Chief Ezego who at the time was the wealthiest man in Nnewi had retained his services to deal with all his (Chief Ezeg...
Post a Comment
Read more

A Panoramic Espousal of the Nature of Nuclear Weapons: Implications of the Production and Stockpiling of the Weapons by North Korea (1)

By Ifeanyi Chukwunonso OGBODO Esq. LL.B (Hons), B.L Email: iogbodo@gmail.com Introduction In his recent state visit to South Korea, President Trump amidst the pomp and ceremony gave an address with  less threats; a stunt recoil of his first speech at the United Nations General Assembly where he stated that United States will totally destroy North Korea if it failed to stop its nuclear programme. Trump devoted a large part of his address to detailing the human rights abuses that the  Kims have committed in North Korea, filling his speech with words like “tyrant” “fascism” and “cult”. He painfully described North Korea as not just a home to a dictator with nuclear weapons but 25million people who suffer under him  —malnutrition among children, suppression of religion, forced labour at prison camps where north Koreans endure torture, starvation, rape and murder. The sheer scale of the casualties and destruction resulting from the use of a nuclear weapon in or nea...
Post a Comment
Read more